If your business engages contractors, operates a platform or acts as an intermediary between service providers and customers, the High Court’s recent decision in the long-running Uber payroll tax dispute is one you should pay attention to.
On 4 November 2026, the High Court dismissed Uber Australia’s appeal by a six-to-one majority, confirming that fares remitted by Uber to its drivers were subject to payroll tax under the contractor provisions of NSW payroll tax law (which are broadly similar in other States and Territories).
The outcome means Uber must pay approximately $81 million in payroll tax assessed for the 2015 to 2020 financial years.
What was the argument about?
Uber put forward three main arguments to challenge the payroll tax assessments:
- Drivers supplied transportation services to riders, not to Uber.
- Any services drivers supplied were ancillary to the use of their vehicles and therefore excluded from the contractor provisions.
- The amounts Uber remitted to drivers were not payments for, or in relation to, the performance of work.
The majority of the High Court rejected all three arguments.
Why Uber lost
The Court found that, although drivers were not obliged to accept any particular trip, once a driver accepted a trip request, collected the rider and commenced the journey, the Driver Contract imposed obligations on the driver to transport the rider to their destination.
Those obligations included complying with Uber’s standards concerning vehicle condition, safety, professionalism and service quality.
Importantly, these obligations were owed to Uber. This meant the driving services were supplied to Uber, even though the rider also received the benefit of the journey.
The Court accepted that a single service can be supplied to more than one party at the same time.
The Court also rejected Uber’s argument that the driving services were ancillary to the use of the vehicle. Neither the vehicle nor the driver’s services could sensibly be regarded as secondary to the other. Accordingly, the goods-based exclusion did not apply.
Finally, on the payment question, the Court found that Uber was much more than a passive payment collection agent. Uber set the recommended fare, deducted its service fee and could adjust or cancel fares.
There was a sufficient connection between the driving work performed and the amounts paid to drivers to bring those payments within the contractor provisions as deemed wages.
Why this matters beyond the gig economy
The decision reinforces that payroll tax contractor provisions can apply well beyond traditional employment-style arrangements.
A worker may be a genuine independent contractor for other purposes, including employment law or superannuation, while the business engaging them may still have a payroll tax liability.
Importantly, your business will not automatically fall outside the contractor provisions simply because:
- Workers operate their own businesses.
- Services are delivered to third-party customers.
- Contractors supply their own tools or equipment.
- Your business is described as an intermediary or agent.
- Payments originate from customers rather than your business.
What matters is the substance of the contractual arrangements, the obligations owed by the parties, the nature of the services performed and how payments are structured and flow.
Where to from here?
Payroll tax assessments can potentially span multiple years, with interest and penalties adding significantly to the cost of getting things wrong.
If your business engages contractors or operates a platform or intermediary model, now is a good time to review your arrangements before any payroll tax enquiry begins.
Please contact our office to arrange a review of your contractor arrangements and discuss what this decision could mean for your payroll tax position.
20 November 2026